Who is Cheaper Geico or Progressive? A Complete 2024 Cost Comparison
Who is Cheaper Geico or Progressive? When you search for car insurance, two names pop up everywhere: Geico and Progressive. This is perfectly normal—both are big players in the industry. But the real question is: Which is actually cheaper?People assume Geico is the most “budget-friendly,” but the reality is a little different. The final quote you receive depends on many factors—such as where you live, your driving record, and how much coverage you need.In this guide, I’ll explain real data and specific situations where one company might offer a better deal than another, so you can stop guessing and actually save money.
Quick Verdict: The “Too Long; Didn’t Read” Version
- Choose Geico if: You have a clean driving record, a good credit score, or you’re a student/young driver. Geico is usually the cheapest for low-risk drivers.
- Choose Progressive if: You’ve had a recent accident, a DUI conviction, or you’re a safe driver and are willing to use the Snapshot app. This app tracks your driving and can offer a good discount.
The Bottom Line: Average Premiums Compared
If we look at the national averages for 2024, Geico usually comes out slightly cheaper than Progressive. Whether you want only the legal minimum coverage or a full coverage policy, Geico’s base price is often lower.For example, the national average for full coverage withGeico is approximately $1,731 per year. With Progressive, it’s around $1,960. Both are significantly cheaper than the overall U.S. average of $2,399, but Geico comes out slightly ahead here.
The numbers for common driver profiles look something like this side-by-side:
| Driver Profile | Geico Annual Rate | Progressive Annual Rate | National Average |
| Full Coverage (Clean Record) | $1,731 | $1,960 | $2,399 |
| Minimum Coverage Only | $517 | $638 | $635 |
| Good Driver + Good Credit | $2,058 | $2,120 | – |
| Poor Credit Score | $2,877 | $3,399 | – |
| Recent At-Fault Accident | $3,526 | $3,167 | – |
Quick Note: Geico wins in most of the rate categories, but pay attention to the “At-Fault Accident” line. This is where Progressive is actually cheaper for drivers who have had a recent accident. That’s why it’s so important to shop for insurance based on your exact situation.
Read More:personal-finance/best-ways-to-save-money-every-month-in-2026
Why Your Rates Might Be Different
Insurance companies don’t just guess numbers. They examine “risk factors,” and each company weighs those factors differently.
1. The Credit Score Factor
This is a big factor. According to NerdWallet market data, Progressive penalizes poor credit more strictly than Geico. If your credit score is in the “poor” range, there could be a difference of $500 or more between the two companies, where Geico is slightly more forgiving.
2. High-Risk Driving
If you have a DUI or a history of speeding tickets, the “cheapest” company flips. Progressive is often more welcoming to high-risk drivers and typically offers more competitive rates post-accident. They have a higher tolerance for “non-standard” drivers.
3. Age and Experience
Young drivers, especially those over 25, usually get better rates with Geico. Research shows that Geico’s average rate for this age group is around $2,172, while Progressive’s rate runs around $2,723.
Pro Tip:Always check your ZIP code. Just crossing a state line can change rates by 20% or 30%. What’s cheap in Ohio can be expensive in Florida.
Usage-Based Savings: DriveEasy vs. Snapshot
Both companies have embraced the “telematics” trend—your driving is tracked through an app and rewarded with discounts. If you’re a safe driver, this could be the best way to reduce high premiums.
| Feature | Geico DriveEasy | Progressive Snapshot |
| Initial Signup Discount | Up to 10% | ~$94 average savings |
| Max Renewal Discount | Up to 25% | ~$231 average savings |
| J.D. Power Satisfaction | 837 / 1000 | 816 / 1000 |
If you’re a safe driver and don’t drive past 2 a.m. much, Progressive’s Snapshot program is quite popular for its great discounts. Yes, Geico’s DriveEasy comes out slightly ahead in overall customer satisfaction.
Beyond the Price Tag: Reliability and Service
To be honest, cheap insurance is only good until you don’t have to file a claim. When it comes time for a claim, you want a company that pays without unnecessary arguments.
- Financial Strength: Geico has an A++ (Superior) rating from AM Best, the highest possible rating. Progressive isn’t far behind, with an A+ rating. Both companies are financially strong and have adequate funds to pay claims.
- Customer Complaints: According to the NAIC complaint index, Geico (1.83) receives fewer complaints than Progressive (2.13) relative to its size.
- The Claims Experience:If your car is financed or leased, many drivers say Progressive’s claims process is a little smoother when dealing with lienholders.
A Quick Glance: Pros and Cons
To make a decision fast, the overall “vibe” of both companies, based on the data, is something like this:
Geico
- Pros: Generally cheaper rates for those with a clean driving record; better for students and young drivers; a long list of “affinity” discounts (military, alumni, etc.).
- Cons: Can be quite expensive in the event of an accident; slightly fewer customized “gap” coverage options.
Progressive
- Pros: Much better for those with an accident or DUI; The “Name Your Price” tool helps with budgeting; Snapshot can offer safe drivers significant discounts
- Cons: Rates tend to be significantly higher for those with poor credit scores.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is Geico really the cheapest insurance company?
For many people, yes—especially if you have a clean driving record and good credit. But “cheapest” doesn't mean the same thing. If you have a DUI or a recent at-fault accident on your record, Progressive or a local company may be cheaper than Geico.
Does Progressive actually use the "Name Your Price" tool?
Yes, absolutely. It's an actual tool on their website. You tell them how much you want to pay, and they show you different coverage options within that budget. This makes it easy to understand how changing your deductible affects your monthly bill.
Which company is better for college students?
Geico usually comes out ahead here. They offer a "Good Student" discount (usually requires a B average or better), which is more generous than Progressive in many cases. Furthermore, Geico's base rates for drivers under 25 are generally lower.
Can I switch from Geico to Progressive (or vice versa) in the middle of my policy?
Absolutely. There's no need to wait for the policy to expire. Most companies will refund your unused premiums. Just keep one thing in mind—cancel the old one as soon as the new policy becomes active, so there's no gap in coverage.
How to Make the Final Call
I always say this: Don’t choose a company based on insurance ads. Make a decision based on your data. Here’s my simple 5-step checklist:
- Run Two Quotes Simultaneously: Open the Geico and Progressive websites in two separate tabs and enter the same coverage limits (e.g., 100/300/100 liability).
- Check for “Hidden” Discounts: Ask about military background, alumni associations, or employer discounts. Geico is well-known for its extensive affinity discount list.
- Bundle Your Policies: If you have renters or homeowners insurance, see which company offers a better multi-policy discount. This can reduce the total cost by 10–25%.
- Consider Your Driving Record:If your record is a little messy, try Progressive first. If it’s clean, start with Geico.
- Re-Shop Every Year: Rates change. The best deal today won’t necessarily be the same 12 months later.
Final Verdict
Geico is the winner for most drivers, especially those with good credit and a clean driving record. But for high-risk drivers, or those who can take full advantage of the Snapshot program, Progressive is a strong option.
Disclaimer: Car insurance rates vary by individual. The numbers in this article are based on national averages and market research as of 2024. Your personal quotes may vary significantly depending on your unique profile.
